Rentvesting is simple to describe. You keep renting where you want to live, and you buy an investment property somewhere you can actually afford. The tenant helps pay that loan, and you get a foot in the market without giving up the suburb, the commute or the beach.
We get asked about it a lot by renters on the Northern Beaches and the lower North Shore. Usually it's a couple in their late twenties or thirties, both working, renting a two-bedroom place in Freshwater or Neutral Bay, who've worked out that buying the same thing would stretch them further than they're comfortable with. Rentvesting can be a good answer. It can also cost you more than you expect if you don't know where the traps are.
How rentvesting works
You buy a property as an investment, rent it out, and keep paying rent on the place you live in. The investment is often in a cheaper part of Sydney, a regional centre or another state. The idea is that the property grows in value over time and builds equity you can later put towards a home you'd actually live in, or use to buy a second investment.
It isn't a shortcut or a tax trick. It's two separate decisions made at once: where you want to live, and what you can afford to own. Rentvesting just stops the first one from deciding the second.
The first home buyer catch
This is the part most people miss, and it's the one we'd want you to understand before anything else.
Most first home buyer help only applies to a home you live in. The federal 5% Deposit Scheme requires you to move in and live there. The NSW stamp duty exemptions and concessions for first home buyers have an owner-occupier requirement as well. So you generally can't use them to buy an investment.
And once you own an investment property, you're usually no longer a first home buyer at all. When you later buy a home to live in, you may not qualify for those schemes either. On a Sydney purchase the stamp duty saving alone can run to tens of thousands of dollars, and avoiding lenders mortgage insurance through the deposit scheme can be worth a lot more. Rentvesting means giving that up, so the investment has to earn its keep.
That doesn't make it a bad idea. It means doing the sums both ways: what you'd save by buying your first home with the concessions, against what you might gain by owning an investment sooner.
How lenders look at a rentvestor
Lenders assess an investment loan differently from a home loan in a few ways that matter here.
- Your own rent counts as an expense. The rent you pay on the place you live in goes into the lender's assessment the same way a mortgage repayment would. A high rent on the Beaches can cut your borrowing power noticeably.
- Only part of the rental income is counted. Lenders usually shade the expected rent to allow for vacancies, management fees and costs, so they won't count every dollar the tenant pays.
- Investment loans are often priced higher. Many lenders charge more for investment lending than for owner-occupied loans, and interest-only investment loans can carry a higher rate again.
- The property still has to suit the lender. Very small units, some regional towns and properties in investor-heavy buildings can limit how much a lender will lend against them.
Put together, a rentvestor often borrows a bit less than they'd guess from looking at the rent the property will earn. Our borrowing power calculator gives a rough starting point, but a broker can run it properly against a few lenders' policies.
The tax side, briefly
This is general information only, and it's worth sitting down with an accountant before you buy.
Interest, property management fees, insurance, council rates and repairs on an investment property are generally tax-deductible. If those costs are more than the rent, the loss can usually be offset against your other income, which is what people mean by negative gearing. That helps with cash flow, but you're still losing money each year and relying on growth to come out ahead.
When you sell, capital gains tax generally applies, because the main residence exemption covers the home you live in, not one you've only ever rented out. If you later move into the property yourself, the rules get more involved. NSW land tax can also apply to investment properties once the land value is above the threshold, and if you own more than one property the land values are added together.
A worked example
Take a couple renting in Freshwater. They have a healthy deposit saved, but the houses they'd want to live in are well out of reach, and a unit nearby would mean stretching their borrowing to the limit for something they'd outgrow in a few years.
Instead, they buy a house further out with a 10 per cent deposit, keep renting near the beach, and put the investment loan on interest-only for the first few years to keep the cash flow manageable. They know they're giving up the first home buyer concessions, so they hold back part of their savings in an offset account as a buffer for vacancies and repairs rather than putting every dollar into the deposit.
If the property grows, the equity can later go towards a home on the Beaches, either by selling or by using the equity as a deposit while keeping the investment. Our guide to how much equity you can use explains how lenders calculate that.
This is an illustration, not a recommendation. Whether it works depends on the property, how long they hold it, and what happens to rates and rents in between.
When rentvesting tends to work
- You're happy renting long term and the place you rent is stable.
- You'd be buying a home you'd outgrow quickly anyway.
- Your income is solid and you have a buffer for vacancies, repairs and rate rises.
- You plan to hold the investment for years, not flip it.
- You've compared it honestly against buying your first home with the concessions.
When it doesn't
- Your rent is already eating a big share of your income. Adding an investment loan on top leaves very little room.
- You'd be buying somewhere you've never been, purely off a spreadsheet or a seminar. Distance makes it harder to judge the property and to manage it.
- You really want stability: a home you can paint, renovate and stay in without a lease ending. That's a fair reason to buy where you live.
- The first home buyer concessions you'd give up are worth more than the growth you can reasonably expect.
Setting up the loan
A few structuring points we'd usually raise with a rentvestor:
- Keep the investment loan separate from any personal debt, so the interest stays clean for tax purposes.
- Consider an offset account rather than paying extra off the investment loan, so the money stays available if you buy a home later. Our offset vs redraw guide explains why.
- Look at whether interest-only suits the first few years, and what happens to the repayment when it ends.
- Think about the next purchase now. The lender and structure you choose for the first property can make the second one easier or harder.
Talk it through with us
We're mortgage brokers based in Forestville, and a lot of our clients rent on the Northern Beaches or the North Shore while they work out their first purchase. We'll run the numbers both ways, as a first home and as a rentvest, across 60+ lenders. Get in touch or call 1300 001 755.
Frequently asked questions
What is rentvesting?
Rentvesting means renting the home you live in and buying an investment property somewhere else, usually somewhere more affordable. The rent from the investment helps cover its loan while you keep living where you want.
Can I use the 5% Deposit Scheme to rentvest?
Generally no. The 5% Deposit Scheme is for owner-occupiers, so you need to move into the property. The same applies to the NSW first home buyer stamp duty concessions.
Will I still be a first home buyer after rentvesting?
Usually not. Owning an investment property generally means you no longer qualify as a first home buyer for the federal deposit scheme or the NSW stamp duty concessions when you later buy a home to live in.
Does my rent affect how much I can borrow?
Yes. Lenders count the rent you pay as a living cost, and they usually only count part of the rent the investment property will earn. Both can reduce your borrowing power.
Is rentvesting a good idea?
It depends on your income, your buffers, the property and how long you plan to hold it. It's worth comparing the numbers against buying your first home with the first home buyer concessions before you decide.
General information only. It does not take your objectives, financial situation or needs into account, and it is not credit or financial advice. Lender policy, rates and eligibility change regularly and vary between lenders — talk to us about your own circumstances before acting on anything here.